Syrian Kurds Without Civil Registration Face Identity Verification Challenges in German Naturalization Procedures

Syrian Kurds Without Civil Registration Face Identity Verification Challenges in German Naturalization Procedures
Syrian Kurds Without Civil Registration Face Identity Verification Challenges in German Naturalization Procedures

Legal Study

Syrian Kurds Without Civil Registration and the Challenge of Proving Identity in Naturalization Procedures

A Legal Study Addressed to the Competent Authorities of the Federal Republic of Germany

By Attorney Fahad Dawoud

Introduction

The issue of Syrian Kurds without civil registration is one of the oldest legal and humanitarian cases whose consequences continue to this day, despite more than six decades having passed since its emergence.

The roots of the issue date back to the exceptional census conducted in Hasaka Governorate on October 5, 1962. The census resulted in a series of political measures that deprived tens of thousands of Syrian Kurdish citizens of Syrian nationality and divided them into different legal categories, most notably “Hasaka foreigners” and people without civil registration, known as Maktoum al-qayd.

The effects of the census were not limited to the first generation but extended to children and grandchildren, resulting in entire generations being born outside the civil registration system. This deprived them of numerous basic rights, foremost among them legal personality, official documents, and citizenship on an equal basis with other Syrian citizens—in clearer terms, the right to live as a recognized person.

As a result, many people without civil registration were unable to obtain official birth certificates, identity cards, civil registry records, or passports, or to own property, register marriages, or register their children. They were also deprived of access to education and university degrees, directly affecting their enjoyment of civil, political, social, and economic rights.

Although Legislative Decree No. 49 of 2011 granted citizenship to the category known as “Hasaka foreigners,” the status of those without civil registration remained without a comprehensive solution.

In 2012, a circular known as Ministerial Notice No. 404 was issued by the Ministry of Interior, alongside the implementation of Civil Status Law No. 13 of 2021 under Article 20. However, the process was limited to security approval. A small number of people without civil registration were eventually naturalized, but only with great difficulty. Those who left Syria during the years of conflict, meanwhile, possess no civil documentation other than identification certificates issued by the local neighborhood mukhtar.

In 2026, Decree No. 13 was issued to address one of the outstanding national and humanitarian issues dating back to the exceptional census of 1962 in Hasaka Governorate and the legal consequences it imposed on a broad segment of the population.

Article 4 of the decree states: “Abolishing all laws and exceptional measures resulting from the 1962 census and granting Syrian citizenship to the citizens covered by its provisions, including those without civil registration, while granting them full equality in rights and duties.”

The study raises a legal reservation regarding the use of the phrase “granting citizenship” in terms of its precise legal characterization. In legal terminology, “granting” implies the creation of a new legal relationship whose effects begin from the date of the decision and apply prospectively.

The case under consideration, however, does not concern the creation of a new legal status. Rather, it concerns the removal of the consequences of an exceptional measure that resulted in the unlawful deprivation of registration or nationality. Accordingly, the more precise legal characterization would be “restoration of citizenship” rather than “granting citizenship,” meaning that the decision should recognize a pre-existing right rather than create a new one.

Adopting the term “restoration” would be consistent with the principle of fully removing the consequences of exceptional measures, reinforce the principle of full equality stipulated in the same article, and prevent any interpretation that could diminish the legal status or political and civil rights of those covered by the decree.

With regard to Decision No. 144 of 2026, issued by the Ministry of Interior to implement the decree, the study argues that the decision emptied the decree of its substance by limiting implementation instructions to those inside Syria. As for those outside the country, practical implementation has revealed a legal gap concerning people residing abroad. The decree does not regulate procedures for approaching embassies or consulates, nor does it establish a mechanism for obtaining the necessary documents. As a result, this group remains unable to benefit from the decree despite being legally entitled to do so. The study further notes that Syrian authorities generally refrain from issuing any document confirming that a person is without civil registration, meaning that such individuals cannot obtain any official documentation of their own and are therefore not legally recognized.

First: The Legal Nature of Persons Without Civil Registration

Article 1 of the Syrian Nationality Law defines a “Syrian Arab” as a person holding Syrian Arab nationality.

Under Syrian law, a person without civil registration is someone who does not hold Syrian nationality, lives on Syrian territory, and has no entry in the Syrian civil status registers. Such a person is treated as a foreigner but without any documentation. Consequently, administrative authorities cannot issue documents whose issuance requires the existence of a prior civil registry entry. Therefore, the failure of a person without civil registration to possess a passport or any official document does not constitute a refusal to obtain one, but rather results directly from the absence of a legal basis allowing such a document to be issued.

Second: The Challenge in German Naturalization Procedures

The general rules governing German naturalization procedures require applicants to provide a national passport or official documents proving their identity.

This requirement serves its purpose for people who are able to approach the authorities of their countries and obtain official documents. However, applying the requirement to Syrian Kurds without civil registration effectively requires them to provide a document that they are legally and practically unable to obtain, because they have no civil registry entry that would allow such a document to be issued.

Article 10(1) of Germany’s Nationality Act (Staatsangehörigkeitsgesetz – StAG) stipulates that one of the conditions for naturalization is that: “seine Identität und Staatsangehörigkeit geklärt sind” meaning that the person’s identity and nationality must have been established.

Accordingly, the legal provision does not state absolutely that identity can be established only through a passport.

Rather, it sets out the legal objective: clarification of identity and nationality.

Article 8(1) of the StAG likewise requires identity and nationality to be established in cases of naturalization under that provision.

This distinction is particularly important in the case of people without civil registration.

The legal requirement is to establish identity, not to compel a person to submit a document that is known in advance to be unobtainable.

Third: Judgment of the German Federal Administrative Court BVerwG 1 C 27.24

The German Federal Administrative Court (Bundesverwaltungsgericht) issued its judgment on December 18, 2025, in case BVerwG 1 C 27.24.

The judgment directly addressed the issue of proving identity in naturalization procedures and developed what is known as the Stufenmodell, or staged model, for establishing identity.

The court ruled that, as a general rule, a naturalization applicant proves his or her identity using a passport.

However, the court established an important qualification: if an applicant does not possess a passport and obtaining one is objectively impossible (objektiv nicht möglich) or subjectively unreasonable under the circumstances (subjektiv nicht zumutbar), the applicant may resort to other means of establishing identity.

The court also affirmed that if another official identity document cannot be provided, the applicant may move to subsequent stages of evidentiary means, provided that the applicant has cooperated sufficiently and that the evidence presented is mutually consistent and consistent with the applicant’s statements concerning his or her identity.

According to the study, this judgment provides an important legal basis for the case of Syrian Kurds without civil registration.

It argues that established legal principles hold that the impossible cannot be required and that an inability resulting from circumstances beyond a person’s control should not constitute grounds for depriving that person of a legal right.

The study therefore argues that the legal solution to this dilemma exists within German law and jurisprudence itself, particularly through the staged model reaffirmed by the Federal Administrative Court in its recent judgment, BVerwG 1 C 27.24.

Accordingly, the study calls on the competent German authorities to treat these cases as exceptional cases requiring individual assessment, a balanced evaluation of evidence, practical application of the principle of proportionality, and acceptance of alternative means of proof when it is established that obtaining a passport or official documents is impossible.

Fourth: International Obligations

Article 6 of the Universal Declaration of Human Rights recognizes the right of every person to recognition everywhere as a person before the law.

This provision is particularly relevant to people without civil registration, as the core of the problem is that individuals have grown up or lived without full civil registration recognizing their legal personality in their country of origin.

Article 15 of the declaration also states that everyone has the right to a nationality and that no one shall be arbitrarily deprived of nationality or denied the right to change it.

International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights Article 16 of the International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights is particularly relevant, as it provides that everyone has the right to recognition everywhere as a person before the law.

Article 8 of the European Convention on Human Rights protects private and family life.

The Council of Europe has also clarified that the scope of protection of private life under Article 8 is linked to elements of personal identity, including a person’s name, civil status, and personal identity.

Legal and human rights bodies have sought to promote channels through which people without civil registration residing outside Syria could resolve their status through embassies and consulates.

However, the absence of a comprehensive practical mechanism for such cases has left the obstacle unresolved.

Fifth: Recommendations

The study calls on the competent authorities in the Federal Republic of Germany to: Recognize the special legal status of Syrian Kurds without civil registration when considering naturalization applications.

Not require a Syrian passport or any other document when it is established that obtaining one is impossible. Accept alternative means of proving identity.

Make use of reports issued by international organizations, legal experts, and lawyers specializing in Syrian affairs to verify the status of people without civil registration.

Consider that the absence of official documents is a direct consequence of the historical deprivation of civil registration, rather than a failure on the part of the naturalization applicant.

Open dialogue with the competent Syrian authorities and international organizations to establish legal mechanisms enabling people without civil registration residing outside Syria to resolve their status and obtain documents that can legally be issued through embassies, diplomatic missions, and consulates.

Conclusion

The issue of people without civil registration is not merely a matter of missing documents. It is the result of exceptional historical and legal circumstances whose consequences have persisted for decades. The study argues that Decree No. 13 of 2026 constitutes compelling evidence and an explicit acknowledgment by the Syrian government of their legal status. Justice, the study argues, does not mean applying the same rule mechanically to different circumstances. Rather, it means applying the law in a manner that takes genuine differences in circumstances into account and prevents the inability to obtain a document from becoming a legal penalty imposed on a person who was not responsible for that inability.

The study concludes by calling on the competent German authorities to adopt a flexible legal approach that balances identity-verification requirements with the constitutional and humanitarian principles underpinning the Federal Republic of Germany, while ensuring justice and the rule of law.

Footnotes

(1) – Legislative Decree No. 13, Article 4, 2026.

(2) – Quoted from the legal memorandum submitted by the Legal Committee of the Kurdish National Council to the Syrian government.

(3) – Legislative Decree No. 276 of 1969, Article 1.

(4) – German Nationality Act (Staatsangehörigkeitsgesetz – StAG), Section 10, Paragraph 1, official text published on the Federal Ministry of Justice’s Federal Legal Information Portal.

(5) – German Nationality Act (Staatsangehörigkeitsgesetz – StAG), Section 8, Paragraph 1, official text published on the Federal Ministry of Justice’s Federal Legal Information Portal.

(6) – German Federal Administrative Court (Bundesverwaltungsgericht), judgment issued on December 18, 2025, Case No. BVerwG 1 C 27.24, titled: “Further Development of the Staged Model for Establishing Identity in Naturalization Proceedings” (Fortentwicklung des Stufenmodells zur Identitätsklärung im Einbürgerungsverfahren), on the official website of the German Federal Administrative Court.

(7) – Universal Declaration of Human Rights, Articles 6 and 15.

(8) – International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights, Article 16.

(9) – European Convention on Human Rights, Article 8, concerning the protection of private and family life.